Where to Put Your Effort in a Competition
When I approach a competition, I look at two things separately: what the schedule requires and how the design will be assessed.
The schedule gives me the problem, or what is required, namely the theme. It also defines dimensions, restrictions and other constraints to work within. The marking criteria tell me how my work will be assessed. They are, essentially, the goal posts. They give me guidance on where to direct my efforts and in what proportion.
Knowing the marking criteria before I start designing tells me where the goal posts are. Each competition allocates marks differently and may use different terminology. Understanding how the judges will assess my work gives me a map to guide me as I develop my response to the brief.
It's easy to become absorbed in one part of an entry. We might put a lot of effort into interpreting the theme while giving less attention to the design principles, colour, impact or workmanship. Or we might fall short in the marking by focusing on design decisions and workmanship at the expense of interpretation. Knowing how these areas are being assessed helps me keep them all in balance as I plan and as I work.
I continue to use the criteria as the design develops. I habitually look at the work and ask where my design meets the criteria and where it falls short. If one aspect has received most of my attention, another may need further development.
This doesn't mean turning the marking criteria into a formula for allocating time. A lower allocation of marks does not make an area unimportant. Workmanship, for example, affects how the whole design is perceived. Compliance is different again: failing to meet the requirements of the schedule may mean an entry is not judged at all.
Returning to the criteria when I review the finished work helps me look beyond whether I simply like the result and consider how effectively it answers the brief. I then return to the schedule separately for a final compliance check. Doing this helps me crystallise learnings that I can carry forward and so become a better designer.
I've shared other insights from my competition experience in the video Top Tips for Competition Success. It's free and you can watch it here.